The William J. Mottola Athletics Hall of Fame
| Name | Graduation Year | Induction Year | Sport(s) |
| Ed Biggie | Contributor | 2008 | Football, Wrestling |
| Joseph "Joe" Clark | 1983 | 2009 | Football |
| Jack Cutliffe | 1955 | 2007 | Football, Basketball, and Baseball |
| Kenneth "Swede" Erickson | 1950 | 2004 | Football, Basketball, and Baseball |
| Bob Fauvell | 1974 | 2007 | Football and Wrestling |
| Dave Fenderson | 1956 | 2005 | Football |
| Robert Giamotti | Contributor | 2005 | Sports Information |
| Emile "Bevo" Girard | 1964 | 2010 | Football |
| Fred Gleason | 1964 | 2011 | Football |
| Ernold "Ernie" Goodwin | 1961 | 2011 | Football |
| Fred J. Haley | 1965 | 2006 | Supporter |
| Kent Higgins | 1966 | 2011 | Men's Basketball |
| John Hoctor | Contributor | 2004 | Football, Basketball, and Baseball |
| Albert "Al" W. Lay | 1975 | 2005 | Football, Wrestling |
| Vanessa LeBlond (Vigue) | 2000 | 2008 | Women's Basketball |
| Rob Marchitello | 1996 | 2004 | Football |
| Kirk Matthieu | 1995 | 2008 | Football |
| Joseph "Joe" Moran | 1964 | 2010 | Football |
| William J. Mottola | Contributor | 2004 | Football, Wrestling, and Baseball |
| Charlie Raymond | 1965 | 2009 | Football |
| Adam St. John | 1985 | 2010 | Men's Basketball |
| Len Tyler | Contributor | 2009 | Football and Basketball |
| Bolma C. "B.C." Voyou | 1996 | 2006 | Men's Soccer |
| Davis E. "Dave" Wiggin | Contributor | 2007 | Football |
| James "Zeke" Zedalis | 1962 | 2009 | Football, Basketball, and Baseball |
